Navegar

Colección

Datos Estadísticas

Artículo

Estamos trabajando para incorporar este artículo al repositorio
Consulte el artículo en la página del editor
Consulte la política de Acceso Abierto del editor

Abstract:

Very few-if any-will doubt Hobbes's aversion to the state of nature and sympathy for civil society. On the other hand, it is not quite news that it would be inaccurate to claim that Hobbes rejected the state of nature entirely. Indeed, he embraced or at the very least tolerated the state of nature at the international level in order to escape from the individual state of nature. Hobbes's recommended exchange of an individual state of nature for an international one does seem to have a smack of contradiction, arguably first noted by Rousseau. There is yet another charge of contradiction lurking around Hobbes's account of the state of nature. Hobbes's political thought would still reflect an ambivalent attitude towards a third instantiation of the state of nature, i.e. civil war. This is one of the main reasons why the political allegiance of Thomas Hobbes has been an issue ever since the publication of De Cive at the very least. This paper deals with Hobbes's differential treatment of the original and the international states of nature and discusses the source of Hobbes's somewhat ambivalent attitude towards civil war. It is here argued that Hobbes can fairly hold his ground vis-à-vis Rousseau's criticism, in spite of the normative resemblance between the international state of nature and the initial state of nature, and that Hobbes ambivalent attitude of attraction and repulsion towards civil war is actually due not so much to opportunism on his part as to the normative autonomy he has granted to the state of nature. © 2011 BRILL.

Registro:

Documento: Artículo
Título:Odi et Amo? Hobbes on the state of nature
Autor:Rosler, A.
Filiación:National Council of Scientific and Technological Research (CONICET), Argentina
Department of Philosophy of Law, Faculty of Philosophy and Letters, University of Buenos Aires, La Pampa 1839 Apt 6 A, 1428 Buenos Aires, Argentina
Palabras clave:civil war; negative association; State of nature; war
Año:2011
Volumen:24
Número:1
Página de inicio:91
Página de fin:111
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/187502511X563826
Título revista:Hobbes Studies
Título revista abreviado:Hobbes. Stud.
ISSN:09215891
Registro:https://bibliotecadigital.exactas.uba.ar/collection/paper/document/paper_09215891_v24_n1_p91_Rosler

Referencias:

  • Hobbes, T., (1996) Leviathan, 88, p. 89. , 2nd revised student edition, ed. with an introduction by Richard Tuck (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press), [1651 = 62]
  • Hobbes, T., (1983) De Cive. The Latin Version, p. 79. , ed. H. Warrender (Oxford, Oxford University Press)
  • Leviathan, 13, p. 90. , [1651 = 63]
  • Rousseau, J.-J., (1985) Discours sur L'origine et les Fondements de L'inégalité Parmi les Hommes, p. 109. , ed. by Jean Starobinski (Paris, Gallimard)
  • Parkin, J., (2007) Taming the Leviathan. The Reception of the Political and Religious Ideas of Thomas Hobbes in England, 1640-1700, 9, p. 61. , Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 87
  • Collins, J.R., (2005) The Allegiance of Thomas Hobbes, pp. 58-59. , Oxford, Oxford University Press
  • Hoekstra, K., The de facto Turn in Hobbes's Political Philosophy (2004) Leviathan after 350 Years, pp. 33-73. , Tom Sorell and Luc Foisneau (eds.), (Oxford, Oxford University Press)
  • Tönies, F., (1971) Thomas Hobbes: Leben und Lehre, p. 215. , ed. Karl-Heinz Ilting (Stuttgart- Bad Cannstatt, Frommann-Holzboog Verlag)
  • Hoekstra, K., (1998) The Savage, the Citizen, and the Foole: The Compulsion for Civil Society in the Philosophy of Thomas Hobbes, pp. 42-43. , Oxford, Oxford University D.Phil. dissertation
  • Yeats, W.B., (2000) Selected Poems, p. 124. , rev. ed. by Timothy Webb (London, Penguin)
  • Hoekstra, K., Hobbes on the natural condition of mankind (2007) The Cambridge Companion to Hobbes's 'Leviathan', p. 111. , Patricia Springborg (ed.), (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
  • Molesworth, W., (1839) Opera Philosophica, 2. , London
  • Hobbes, T., (1994) Leviathan, (7), p. 77. , ed. by E. Curley (Indianapolis, Hackett)
  • Hobbes, T., (1998) On the Citizen, p. 26. , ed. by R. Tuck and Michael Silverthorne (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press)
  • Leviathan, 15, p. 106. , [1651 = 76]
  • On the Citizen, 3-9, p. 48
  • Hobbes, T., (1994) The Elements of Law, Natural and Politic, 16 (8), pp. 90-91. , ed. by J. C. A. Gaskin (Oxford, Oxford University Press)
  • The Elements of Law, 17 (1), p. 93
  • The Elements of Law, 17 (2), p. 94
  • The Elements of Law, 14 (11), p. 80
  • On the Citizen, 1-12, p. 29
  • Malcolm, N., Hobbes and spinoza (1991) The Cambridge History of Political Thought, 1450-1700, p. 535. , J. Burns (ed.), (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press)
  • Geismann, G., Herb, K., (1988) Hobbes Über Die Freiheit, 24 (5), p. 118. , (Wüzburg, Köigshausen & Neuman), 129
  • On the Citizen, 17-27, pp. 231-232
  • On the Citizen, 3 (4), p. 45
  • On the Citizen, 14 (9), p. 158
  • On the Citizen, 10 (1), p. 115
  • On the Citizen, 14 (1), p. 154
  • The Elements of Law, 13 (6), p. 76
  • On the Citizen, 5-7, p. 72
  • Leviathan, 17, pp. 120-121. , [1651 = 87-8]
  • Hoekstra, K., The Savage, the Citizen, and the Foole, p. 21
  • Evrigenis, I.D., (2007) Fear of Enemies and Collective Action, p. 119. , Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
  • On the Citizen, 6 (2), p. 77
  • Tuck, R., (1993) Philosophy and Government, 1572-1651, pp. 105-106. , Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
  • Leviathan, 25, p. 182. , [1651 = 136]
  • Tuck, R., The Rights of War and Peace, p. 32
  • Shaw, B.D., Bandits in the Roman empire (1984) Past & Present, 105 (1), p. 21
  • Cicero, (1991) On Duties, 3, p. 108. , ed. by M. T. Griffi n and E. M. Atkins (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press), 142
  • Rousseau, J.-J., Écrits sur l'Abbé de Saint-Pierre (1964) Oeuvres Complètes, 3, p. 564. , ed. by Sven Stelling-Michaud, (Paris, Gallimard)
  • Caney, S., (2006) Justice beyond Borders, p. 270. , Oxford, Oxford University Press
  • Leviathan, 29, p. 221. , [1651 = 167]
  • Gat, A., (2008) War in Human Civilization, 131 (2), pp. 408-409. , Oxford, Oxford University Press
  • Baumgold, D., (1988) Hobbes's Political Theory, p. 87. , Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
  • Gat, A., War and Human Civilization, p. 131
  • Rousseau, J.-J., Du Contract Social (1964) Oeuvres Complètes, p. 357. , ed. by R. Derathè, (Paris, Gallimard)
  • Schmitt, C., (1950) Der Nomos der Erde im Völkerrecht des Jus Publicum Europaeum, 91, pp. 114-115. , Berlin, Duncker & Humblot
  • On the Citizen, 3 (54), p. 27
  • On the Citizen, 10-17, p. 126
  • Leviathan, 21, p. 151
  • Leviathan, 28, p. 214. , [1651 = 161]
  • Leviathan, 14, p. 98. , [1651 = 70]
  • Leviathan, 27, p. 207. , [1651 = 156]
  • Du Contract Social, 1-5, p. 376
  • On the Citizen, 10 (7), pp. 120-121
  • On the Citizen, 13 (13), p. 149
  • Strong, T.B., (1996) The Concept of the Political, p. 46. , (Chicago, The University of Chicago Press), 47
  • The Concept of the Political, p. 53
  • Richard II, 1-3, pp. 279-280

Citas:

---------- APA ----------
(2011) . Odi et Amo? Hobbes on the state of nature. Hobbes Studies, 24(1), 91-111.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/187502511X563826
---------- CHICAGO ----------
Rosler, A. "Odi et Amo? Hobbes on the state of nature" . Hobbes Studies 24, no. 1 (2011) : 91-111.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/187502511X563826
---------- MLA ----------
Rosler, A. "Odi et Amo? Hobbes on the state of nature" . Hobbes Studies, vol. 24, no. 1, 2011, pp. 91-111.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/187502511X563826
---------- VANCOUVER ----------
Rosler, A. Odi et Amo? Hobbes on the state of nature. Hobbes. Stud. 2011;24(1):91-111.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/187502511X563826